The Gap
In this country, public education is for everyone. The “haves” and “have-nots” are both entitled to go to public schools. Because schools are organized around local school boards and communities, sometimes there is an economic disparity from one school community to another. This isn’t news to anyone. But when we talk about the gap in technology, the economic gap plays heavily.
I work in a suburban, middle class, blue-collar community. The school is the focus of a lot of activity, arts, athletics and academics, and we are very proud of our school. Financially, our school doesn’t carry a lot of debt and our facilities are well kept. We vote to pass our budgets each year, and we are competitive with other schools of similar size and demographics. So, on the whole, we are in pretty good shape. But we still have a gap.
Computer technology is very expensive. You could argue that the prices have come down considerably, but the truth is they never get down to zero. Schools have a tendency to purchase computer equipment in spurts. We get a grant or a bond issue, and we buy a lot of computers and then we coast for a couple of years. Depending on the economy, the tax rate, the local politics, sometimes we coast for longer. Then we get the Technology Gap.
The Technology Gap is the difference between what we have currently, and what we should have. Notice I did not say what we would like to have. The truth is we computer people always want something new, something faster. But what we actually need is usually less. Unless we have coasted too long.
You can tell if your school has coasted too long. If the technology that students are bringing in from home is better than what you have at school, you have coasted too long. If your faculty has better machines at home than they do at school, you’ll know. Network people hate this because suddenly they are being inundated with calls to allow people to connect their personal machines to the school network. Of course in the private sector you would be taken out and shot for that, but schools are a different story.
The truth is that teachers buy stuff for their students and classrooms all the time. Sure we have a budget, sure the school provides us with materials and equipment. But sometimes we buy things because it is the path of least resistance. Even computers. I know two different teachers, in my building alone, who bought their own data projectors just so they would always have access and not have to worry about whether someone else had signed it out or not. These machines are not cheap! But the gap between what the teachers needed (or wanted…) was greater than the school district could afford at the time.
In my district we are starting to see a gap with our operating system. I mentioned in a previous column that I purchased a new gradebook program that was native to OS X on my G4 laptop so I could escape from OS 9. The gradebook program is great and every bit as good if not better than what our administrative computer network has. But I still needed to support myself on the Mac platform.
Our school network gap is between Windows 2000 and Windows XP. The district uses Windows 2000. But, almost every student in all my classes uses XP at home. I mean every single one!
When we migrated from Mac to PC’s, one of the reasons often cited was, “We need our kids to use what they are using out in the Real World.” The fact that we were already using M$ Office was kind of lost in the shuffle. So we use Windows & Office 2000. But, the year is now 2006. Some of the things we are trying to do cannot be done because we are not up-to-date with our software, things such as bringing work back and forth from home. I believe this will all change soon, and we will move up to the next OS and Office Suite. But, when you coast, the gap grows.
There are other gaps too. There is a gap between what kids think they know about computers, and what they really do know. Of course, that is where we educators come in. We de-bunk myths, we educate, we raise the consciousness level. It’s a good job.